The Language of Jazz Improvisation

INTRODUCTION: Good evening. Welcome to the Jazz Club of Sarasota's Educational Lecture Series. This afternoon we're going to explore the similarities between spoken language and jazz improvisation.

Let's start with a question: how is a good speech similar to a good solo?

According to Jeff Ellwood we should play the way we talk: click here


This sounds enigmatic! What does it mean to "play like you talk"?



PART 1: The grammar of jazz solos

The most basic function of speech is to communicate something. It could be an instruction, a warning, or an intention. But at a more sophisticated level, speech can communicate an emotion or a feeling.

Music is just like sophisticated speech. It communicates emotions. But how does it do this without words? Well, it uses the magic of melody, harmony and rhythm which work together to create an unfolding musical narrative.

Just like spoken narrative, a song has a beginning, a middle and an end, and if it has a lyric, it will even evoke images. The harmonies will rise and fall and take the listener on a journey of tension and release. The rhythm may create excitement. The key can be major or minor, which will determine if the overall mood of the story is jolly or sad.

But what happens after the words end and the instrumental solo starts? How does the story continue and develop?

The framework of the song does not change during the solo, because the chords stay the same. What captures the listener's attention is the WAY THE SOLOIST DESCRIBES THE CHORDS.

What's even more fascinating is that each soloist will describe the chords in a different way, just as an event will be described differently by different people. This is what intrigues listeners.

Let's compare verbal storytelling with musical storytelling.

Here's a story called A Day In The Life Of Frank. Notice how each version gets more sophisticated.



Here's the musical analogy. The story is called My Heart Stood Still, and is sung by Chet Baker.



What makes these solos so interesting and compelling is the relationship between the notes played and the underlying harmony of the tune, in addition to an impeccable rhythmic drive. These are crucial elements in a good solo, just as the choice of words and their timing is important in conveying an engaging story.

Italian jazz pianist Andrea Pozza explains the relationship between the solo's notes and the harmony very clearly: click here


Andrea just demonstrated the most basic principle of jazz improvisation, that is: describe the chords of a song with a melody. This is equivalent to telling the story of Frank's day in its most basic terms. Just as we can't change the order of things Frank did during the day, we can't change the order of the song's chords. But we can try to describe Frank's day (or the chords of the song) in an exciting and interesting way.

One way to do this is to use interesting musical phrases over the chords, just as a spoken story uses interesting adjectives and sentences.

This brings us to the topic of vocabulary.

The greater your vocabulary, the richer and more descriptive will be your storytelling (be it verbal or musical).

This is what Bruce Harris has to say about vocabulary: click here


Learning jazz vocabulary is like learning words in the English language. The more words you know, the more descriptive your story.

But you also have to learn how to put the words and phrases together in the correct order.

Here is what Charles McPherson has to say about organizing the notes and phrases in a solo: click here





PART 2: Strategies for building a jazz solo vocabulary

Just as we use a phrase book when trying to communicate in a foreign country, we can use a phrase book to learn basic musical phrases. There are hundreds of books that collect thousands of phrases over chord progressions. For example, you can use a website like this like this.

However, this does not teach you how to "seamlessly" connect phrases together in a logical way. To learn this skill, you should study solo transcriptions of master musicians. More specifically, you should play them on your instrument, and if they are too difficult, slow them down. This provides you with first hand experience of how phrases are connected to form solos.

For example, here is a transcribed solo by Barry Harris, broken up into two bar phrases: click here.

As you transcribe more solos, you will discover that some phrases appear more frequently and across multiple songs. This tells us that these phrases are an important part of the vocabulary, and should be prioritized, just as nouns like 'dog', 'cat' or 'bus' are important in the English language: see here

A problem that jazz improvisers frequently face is the fact that there are literally hundreds of tunes that need to be learned in order to be prepared for gig or jam session situations. The solution is not to practice your collection of phrases on individual songs, but to practice on the building blocks of songs, which are recurring, short, chord sequences.

Ralph Patt did an excellent job organizing jazz standards according to their harmonic building blocks. His website.

Barry Harris has even better advice. He suggests focusing on very few songs and mastering the different ways you can solo over them. This will cover most of the situations you will encounter in any new song.

As you practice phrases over chord sequences, always be careful to describe the underlying chords, by playing the correct chord tones at the right time. This video describes this process:

  

So, you see from the above example that the improvised lines both describe the underlying chords and also connect together in a smooth and logical way. If a listener knows the song, and is familiar with the chord progression, he/she will be gratified when the solo satisfies the expected harmonies of the tune. This is how a solo maintains its inner logic.

Here are some verbal analogies:

In this segment, the words do not follow logically, like a solo which does not match the chords:



On the other hand, when the words (or melodic phrases) are ordered correctly, the segment sounds like this:



Adhering closely to the chords in the tune will help the solo sound smooth and logical, just like the second example above.

Since our goal is to tell a story with our solo, sometimes it's helpful to decide ahead of time what kind of story it will be. This will help shape the solo. Will it be lyrical or introspective? Cautious or virtuosic? Based on a single motif or based on multiple motifs? Bluesy or abstract?

For example, we could construct a solo around a motif (or short theme). This bypasses the problem of learning a ton of language before we can play an interesting solo. The motif could be the opening phrase of the song, like, for example: Oh! Look At Me Now: click here.

Gary Burton explains the idea of soloing with a motif in this masterclass: click here.



PART 3: Is it necessary to learn music theory to be a good improviser?


So the short answer is: "no, you don't have to learn music theory to improvise ". When you're soloing, you're not thinking about theory, you're more likely thinking about melodic shapes and the chords of the tune. So why learn scales and study harmony? The reason is that it will help you discover interesting melodic ideas that your ear alone will not lead you to.

Bruce Harris has an interesting insight into learning music theory: click here


Furthermore, understanding music theory will enable you to understand what the master musicians are playing in their solos.

Here is an example of an analysis by Nathan Graybeal of a Barry Harris solo: click here.

Labeling things helps retreive them more readily, and this can be handy when it comes to finding the correct phrases to apply to a song's chord changes. The speed and accuracy of our ears alone has its limits!

Ultimately, I think it's safe to say that learning by ear (which means memorizing phrases on your instruments) and learning music theory are two activities to be developed in parallel.

For those interested in learning more theory, there are endless online resources (which is a good alternative to music school). For example:

Jason Fabus has a short worksheet on bebop language.

John Walsh has a well organize improvisation course.

The Barry Harris Institute of Jazz has various courses based on his famous teaching method.

Educate yourself on basic jazz theory, like major scales, dominant scales, harmonic minor scales, bebop scales, chord tones, guide tones (3rd and 7th), passing tones, approach (or leading) tones, enclosures (or surround notes), and pivots.

Probably the most important piece of music theory for any improviser is knowing what scales go with what chords. This information is all contained in the Jamey Aebersold Scale Syllabus, and there's a good year's worth of work just learning all the scales listed here.

It's also good to know your scales because if you run out of ideas in your solo, you can always play the correct scale over the chord, even though your story will come to a standstill by doing this.

Just playing scales or fishing for notes within the chords is not enough to tell a story or develop ideas. As Charles McPherson said earlier, you need well constructed, "long musical sentences" to develop your ideas and capture the listener's attention. Here's the verbal equivalent of a solo that has no phrases and just plays random chord notes:




As the beginner learns phrases and starts applying them to songs, a story will start to emerge. But if too many of the same phrases and motifs are used over and over again, the lack of variety could be a problem. Here is a verbal equivalent:




Let's imagine that a player starts soloing on a song they don't know, with the idea that they can wing it "by ear" through the chord changes, and that, in any case, they believe that improvisation means having the freedom to do whatever comes to mind in the moment.

Various problems will arise.

Firstly, the band members will not understand what the soloist is doing, because there is very little predictable connection with the chord changes. So interacting constructively will be impossible.

Here is a verbal equivalent of lack of communication between band members::

Secondly, the audience will hear sounds that have no meaning, because they are not relating to the chords and/or don't have a recognizable motif: Here's a linguistic analogy:



In music, gibberish (or random sounds) can be used as an effect, even a gimmick, but are not generally part of a coherent narrative. Fortunately, the main corpus of jazz music is not just random sounds and gibberish. Great innovators like Louis Armstrong, Charlie Parker, John Coltrane and many others have helped develop a coherent jazz vocabulary that goes far beyond just the appeal of their sound.

However, some particularly talented musicians can create an interesting solo by virtue of their creative quirkiness and rhythmic drive, and can get away with not playing standard language:




Playing "outside the box" can sometimes be effective because not everyone responds to music the same way. Musical vocabulary is more flexible than spoken language, because it is abstract rather than task-oriented. Therefore music lends itself to experimentation much more than the spoken word. Some would argue that musical vocabulary is unnecessary provided we are communicating a sensory experience to the listener.

However, I would argue that, when soloing, you need an "aesthetic guiding force", otherwise it becomes all expression and no art. In the words of Bill Evans:



Now that we understand the parallels musical story-telling and verbal story-telling, I'd like to conclude this segment by listening to an interesting idea developed by Charlotte Wassy. She is showing us how the inflections, pauses, rhythms and phrases of a solo by Wayne Shorter can be interpreted as verbal descriptions of a very specific story. The story here is about a shop attendant trying to sell products to a customer.


PART 4: How important is rhythm?

Good musical story-telling also has an important rhythmic component.

Timing is everything!

All your notes should fall on a clear beat. Failing to do this makes the solo sound awkward. Here is a verbal equivalent:

Awkward:

With good rhythm, the delivery is smooth:

Improvisers should work on smooth articulation of the notes.

Steve Sandner has some good advice on how to practice rhythm His website.



Always practice every musical motif or phrase with a good time feel. Practice swinging with a metronome, the iReal, or over the original recording.

Barry Harris frequently intersperses his solos with single note rhythmic pattern: click here. [Barry Harris (p), Bob Cranshaw (b), Clifford Jarvis (dr)]

Here is an example of how piano, bass and drums combine in a perfect rhythmic driving force: click here.

Here is another example of a swinging trio. This is what jazz musicians call "pocket": click here.

Furthermore, you should be able to swing your vocabulary (however limited) by yourself. You shouldn't rely on the drums or the bass to swing. Here's an example of a piano swinging by itself (but this applies to any instrument):

While phrase complexity can be variable, the rhythmic aspect is not negotiable if you want to play authentic jazz. Remember the statement "It don't mean a thing if it ain't got that swing". This holds especially true when you solo.

Learning to swing can only be achieved by imitating a master musician. Pick a solo, learn it, and play with the recording. Absorb its time feel. You can also practice soloing over a Frank Sinatra track from the album Sinatra and Swingin' Brass: click here.

This will engrain in you a solid swing feel.

Unfortunately, an inexperienced rhythm section can completely destroy a solo by killing the swing feel and obfuscating the articulation of phrases. When drum fills, comping chords, or bass notes are in the wrong place, it can negate the swing feel, as well as hinder the proper breathing between phrases. The responsibility of the rhythm section is to inspire the soloist and make his/her lines sound smooth and effortless, and, where possible, to reinforce the musical ideas they are trying to express. Here's an example of a supportive rhythm section click here.


It's stable, smooth, unobstrusive, swinging, and provides just the right amount of rhythmic accents and harmonic cues.



PART 5: Are there different styles of improvisation?



Yes, most certainly! This is the equivalent of speaking a different dialect. Different dialect speakers can communicate with each other, but it may sound a little odd, since different words and pronounciations are used to say the same thing. In music, this can lead to stylistic clashes.


Therefore, before learning vocabulary, it's important to decide what style you want to play in.

I would suggest distinguishing between intervallic soloing (Modal) and chromatic (Bebop) soloing. There are other styles, like Ragtime, Blues, Traditional (or Stride), Swing and Free, but let's focus on these two major styles.

===== Examples of Intervallic soloing =====

McCoy Tyner on What Is This Thing Called Love click here.


Benito Gonzales on Giant Steps (composition that facilitates intervallic playing) click here.

Will Fulkerson on Passion Dance:



===== Examples of Chromatic soloing =====

Barry Harris on What Is This Thing Called Love click here.


Conte Candoli on Owl Eyes (C blues) click here.

 

===== Combining Styles=============

Kellin Hanas suggests that you can incorporate both intervallic and chromatic language in your solo, for contrast:



Once you have chosen your style, and learned lots of vocabulary in that style, and practiced it on important chord changes, you will be ready to improvise.

However, copying solos that you have transcribed, or playing a series of patterns you have memorized, is not improvising.

True improvisation is finding new ways of playing a phrase on the fly. But learning lots of language will equip you to do this. You can't always predict what will emerge from your unconscious during a solo, because external factors, like responding to the rhythm section or the audience's reaction will determine what you feel like expressing. But having lots of tools in your tool kit will enable you to craft good solos on the fly.

Eric Alexander explains the process of improvisation like this: click here.




PART 5: How important is my tone?

Your tone is a very important part of how you present yourself as a soloist. Follow Sherman Irby's advice on developing a good tone: click here or here

And by the way, intonation is not an opinion. Being in tune produces harmony, resonance, and a sense of unity with the other instruments in the band.

Whatever solo you attempt, try to make your sound beautiful, not screeching: click here


PART 6: Should I practice embellishments?




PART 7: Should I be worried? Some Psychological Considerations




PART 8: Conclusion

In this presentation we have seen that jazz solos have the same structure as spoken language, in that they both tell a story.

We have learned that the musical story is the chord progression, and musical vocabulary can be used to describe the chord progression in different ways.

We have looked at the importance rhythm, and explored two different soloing styles.

We have also laid out an action plan for building vocabulary.

In conclusion, I would like to encourage you to set realistic performance goals that are within your reach.

One goal could be to discover (and extend) your true musical potential. Being a jazz musician means committing to growing as a musician. This requires constant, daily study. Otherwise you will always sound the same when you improvise. Musicians who don't want to be creative (and change) can be good section players in an orchestra or big band, or could play a style that doesn't require improvisation.

Try to avoid soloing without a plan. This could lead to what I call the 'cavaleer' solo. Here's a verbal analogy:



Approach learning the language of jazz improvisation like learning a language on the Duolingo app. Create learning streaks! Learn new phrases and tunes every day, and reach a point where you can execute phrases with ease. Constantly add vocabulary, and always practice with a good rhythmic feel.

Here are three habits that WILL lead to improvement:

I call it RRP.

Regularity, repetition and perseverance

By the way, I play in a band called the Foot Note Jazz Band every Tuesday at Latin Quarters on Beneva, from 6 - 8:30, and all the principles discussed above are clearly demonstrate by the soloists in the band. Check it out if you're interested in hearing more live jazz improvisation.

Thank you and happy practicing!